Hospitals Merged. Quality Didn’t Improve (Jan. 1) reports on a study that uses data that is not sufficiently up to date and therefore is of minimal value for assessing the benefits of hospital mergers. It is also at odds with a recent study by Charles River, a leading global consulting firm, which found statistically significant improvements in the rates of readmissions and mortality associated with mergers. Unlike the study cited by the journal, this study did not use patient satisfaction surveys to measure quality; that is not the purpose of such surveys as they measure patient experience rather than more objectively measurable aspects of quality. 
 
As the authors themselves acknowledge, the study suffered from a number of limitations which also bear on its validity, including that it examined the “average effects” of a merger, which “might obscure the benefits.” Neither hospitals nor the communities they serve can be shoe horned into “average effects” when it comes to providing life sustaining care.   
 
The facts are that in addition to improving quality, mergers produce important cost savings and do not increase revenues. And, importantly, mergers can keep hospitals open to serve patients. Entire communities rely on their hospitals as anchors and hospitals often need partners to continue to serve those communities with high quality care that keeps pace with local needs.
 

Related News Articles

Headline
Federal Trade Commissioner Christine Wilson yesterday clarified remarks published in certain publications last month that quoted her saying the agency will…
Headline
A new AHA resource debunks the top eight myths about hospital and health system mergers, such as misconceptions that they lead to higher costs for…
Headline
Hospital mergers are worth discussing, but “too often the criticism is far from rigorous” and “more like an echo chamber,” which does a “disservice to our…
Blog
Hospital mergers are worth discussing, but too often the criticism is far from rigorous or even searching – it’s more like an echo chamber where critics cite…
Headline
In this AHA Stat Blog post, AHA General Counsel Melinda Hatton and others point out a number of flaws in a recent study on hospital consolidation and quality,…
Blog
Chief among the flaws in the most recent study on hospital consolidation published in the New England Journal of Medicine was that its conclusions were…